
Best Courses
New York's Best Golf Courses: What the Rankings Say
Golf Digest's top 60 in New York and its public list, split into private and playable.
Updated · November 19, 2026
New York's golf rankings are lopsided. Most of the state's highest-rated courses are private clubs on Long Island and in Westchester, with a run of Donald Ross courses upstate. The public side is thinner but real: a state park course in Farmingdale ranks No. 7, and one Central New York resort has three ranked courses. This guide reads Golf Digest's two New York lists, separates the private clubs from the courses a visitor can play, and names the edition behind each number.
The lists and the editions
Each position below carries its list and date.
- Golf Digest's Best Golf Courses in New York, 2025-26. Published May 29, 2025: 60 courses, public and private together, each tagged as one or the other. The same page notes that New York has 15 courses on Golf Digest's America's 100 Greatest list, more than any other state.
- Golf Digest's Best Public Golf Courses in New York. Published September 24, 2025: 26 courses a visitor can book. The page does not number them, so a course is "named on" it, never ranked.
- GOLF Magazine's Best Golf Courses in New York, 2024-25. Published December 22, 2024: 40 courses. It appears here only as a cross-check.
Reader-review awards are left out: they measure how much visitors enjoyed a day out, not how good the golf is.
The private top of the list
Fifty-one of the 60 on Golf Digest's 2025-26 list are private clubs, for members and their guests. None sells a round to the public, and no ranking changes that.
Nos. 1-10
All private, for members and their guests, except Bethpage Black.
- No. 1: Shinnecock Hills Golf Club, Southampton. William Flynn's 1931 course on sandy, windswept ground, where the U.S. Open was last played in June 2026.
- No. 2: National Golf Links of America, Southampton. C.B. Macdonald's course on Peconic Bay, built with Seth Raynor: the start of the partnership that spread template holes nationwide.
- No. 3: Fishers Island Club, Fishers Island. Raynor's 1926 course on an island that belongs to New York but is reached by ferry from Connecticut.
- No. 4: Winged Foot Golf Club's West Course, Mamaroneck. A.W. Tillinghast's six-time U.S. Open course.
- No. 5: Friar's Head, Riverhead. Bill Coore and Ben Crenshaw's course, where the holes swing from sand dunes above Long Island Sound to former farmland.
- No. 6: Oak Hill Country Club's East Course, Rochester. Donald Ross's championship course, restored by Andrew Green in 2019; the 2023 PGA Championship was played there.
- No. 7: Bethpage State Park's Black Course, Farmingdale. The one public course in the group, host of two U.S. Opens, the 2019 PGA Championship and the 2025 Ryder Cup.
- No. 8: Winged Foot Golf Club's East Course, Mamaroneck. The shorter of the club's two Tillinghast courses, known for its par 3s.
- No. 9: Sebonack Golf Club, Southampton. Jack Nicklaus and Tom Doak's 2006 collaboration, next door to National.
- No. 10: Sleepy Hollow Country Club, Scarborough. Macdonald and Raynor laid out the first nine above the Hudson; Tillinghast later took the club to 27 holes.
Nos. 11-25
All 15 are private, for members and their guests.
Long Island: Maidstone Club (No. 11), Willie and John Park's 1924 links in the dunes of East Hampton; Garden City Golf Club (No. 12), Devereux Emmet's course on the Hempstead Plain, reworked by Walter Travis; Piping Rock Club (No. 15) and The Creek (No. 16), two Macdonald and Raynor courses in Locust Valley; Atlantic Golf Club (No. 17) and The Bridge (No. 18), both Rees Jones designs, the second on the old Bridgehampton race circuit; Glen Oaks Club (No. 19), ranked for its White and Blue nines; St. George's Golf & Country Club (No. 20), the course Emmet built for himself; and Westhampton Country Club (No. 24), one of Raynor's earliest solo designs.
Westchester: Quaker Ridge Golf Club (No. 13), Tillinghast again, in Scarsdale; Hudson National Golf Club (No. 14), Tom Fazio's 1996 course high above the river; Wykagyl Country Club (No. 22) in New Rochelle; and Westchester Country Club's West Course (No. 23), Travis's 1922 design in Rye.
Further north: Glens Falls Country Club (No. 21), a Ross course in Queensbury that opened in 1914, and Silo Ridge Field Club (No. 25), Tom Fazio's course in Amenia.
Nos. 26-60
Its eight public courses appear in the next section; the 27 private clubs, all for members and their guests, fall like this:
- Westchester: Fenway Golf Club (No. 30), Century Country Club (No. 31), Whippoorwill Club (No. 32), Old Oaks Country Club (No. 42), Sunningdale Country Club (No. 45), Westchester Country Club's South Course (No. 48), Metropolis Country Club (No. 50) and Siwanoy Country Club (No. 60), where the first PGA Championship was played in 1916.
- Nassau County: Deepdale Golf Club (No. 26), Meadow Brook Club (No. 27), The Rockaway Hunting Club (No. 35), Engineers Country Club (No. 41), North Shore Country Club (No. 44), Nassau Country Club (No. 49), Old Westbury Golf & Country Club (No. 53) and The Seawane Club (No. 57).
- The East End: Southampton Golf Club (No. 34), Raynor's 1926 course; East Hampton Golf Club (No. 37), a walking-only Coore and Crenshaw design; and Noyac Golf Club (No. 56).
- Rochester: Oak Hill's West Course (No. 29), Monroe Golf Club (No. 33) and The Country Club of Rochester (No. 43), all three Ross designs.
- Buffalo: The Country Club of Buffalo (No. 28), another Ross; Crag Burn Golf Club (No. 36), Robert Trent Jones Sr.'s 1972 course in East Aurora; and Park Country Club (No. 54), the Colt & Alison course that held the 1934 PGA Championship.
- Elsewhere: The Country Club of Troy (No. 46), Walter Travis's last design, and Manhattan Woods Golf Club (No. 47), Gary Player's course in Rockland County.
Golf Digest's public list
The Best Public Golf Courses in New York list names 26 courses without numbering them. Nine also make the main 60, the highest-rated golf a visitor can book in the state:
- Bethpage Black (No. 7). Walking only. State residents get their own rates and a longer booking window, and Black reservations are limited to one every 28 days.
- Turning Stone's Atunyote Golf Club (No. 38). Tom Fazio's course at the Oneida Indian Nation's resort, where the PGA Tour's Turning Stone Resort Championship was played from 2007 to 2010. Non-guests can book online.
- Bally's Golf Links at Ferry Point (No. 39). Jack Nicklaus's links-style course on a former Bronx landfill, with a separate rate for city residents. Construction for a planned casino has closed the 8th hole for now.
- Turning Stone's Kaluhyat Golf Club (No. 40). Robert Trent Jones Jr.'s hilly course, with the highest slope rating of the resort's three.
- Turning Stone's Shenendoah Golf Club (No. 51). Rick Smith's 2000 course, the resort's first, rebuilt with seven new holes before the 2017 season.
- Leatherstocking Golf Course (No. 52). The Otesaga's 1909 Emmet course in Cooperstown, open to hotel guests and non-guests, with a finish around Otsego Lake.
- Saratoga National Golf Club (No. 55). Roger Rulewich's 2001 daily-fee course in Saratoga Springs, built around carries over wetland and water.
- Pound Ridge Golf Club (No. 58). Pete and Perry Dye's 2008 course, open to all with no residency requirement.
- Montauk Downs State Park Golf Course (No. 59). A Robert Trent Jones Sr. redesign at the eastern tip of Long Island, run by New York State Parks.
The other 17 courses named on the public list:
Long Island and the city. Bethpage's Red Course, the Tillinghast par 70 known as the Baby Black; Harbor Links Golf Course, the Town of North Hempstead's course in a former Port Washington sand mine; The Golf Club at Middle Bay, a former private club on the Oceanside waterfront that now takes public tee times; Smithtown Landing Country Club, the Town of Smithtown's course, where non-residents can play on weekdays but need a resident with them on Fridays, weekends and holidays; and Dyker Beach Golf Course, the city course in Brooklyn below the Verrazzano Bridge.
Hudson Valley and the Catskills. The Monster at Resorts World Catskills, Rees Jones's 2023 rebuild; The Links at Union Vale, a nearly treeless, links-style Stephen Kay course in LaGrangeville; Centennial Golf Club, Larry Nelson's 27 holes in Carmel; The Golf Club at Mansion Ridge, a Jack Nicklaus Signature course in Monroe that mixes daily-fee play with membership; and Patriot Hills Golf Club, the Town of Stony Point's course above the Hudson.
Upstate. The Sagamore Golf Course, Ross's 1928 resort course near Lake George; Seneca Hickory Stick Golf Course, Robert Trent Jones Jr.'s 2010 course in Lewiston; Ravenwood Golf Club in Victor, partway through a renovation expected to finish in 2027; The Links at Greystone in Walworth; Seven Oaks Golf Club, Colgate University's Robert Trent Jones Sr. course in Hamilton; The Links at Hiawatha Landing on the Susquehanna west of Binghamton; and Conklin Players Club, the one name on the list without a course page here yet.
Reading the lists
Geography explains most of the order. Long Island has 27 of the 60 and Westchester 16, and only three of those 43 (Bethpage Black, Montauk Downs and Pound Ridge) are public.
The East End is the summit. Suffolk County holds five of the first ten: Shinnecock, National and Sebonack side by side in Southampton, plus Friar's Head and Fishers Island. The ground is sandy and windswept, and the list rewards both the Golden Age courses built on it and the modern ones that followed.
Westchester is the deepest region and Tillinghast country: the Winged Foot pair in Mamaroneck, Quaker Ridge and Fenway in Scarsdale. Pound Ridge is its only public course on the list. Nassau's North Shore leans toward Macdonald and Raynor, at Piping Rock, The Creek and North Shore, with Bethpage as the county's public anchor.
Upstate, the classics are Ross's: six of the nine upstate private clubs on the list, from Glens Falls and Troy west to Buffalo, are his, and Oak Hill's East is the only upstate course in the first 20. Upstate also holds five of the nine public courses on the 60, and four of them are in Central New York, at Turning Stone and Cooperstown. No other region has more than one, which makes Central New York the natural base for a ranked-golf trip.
The gap in the middle is the other lesson: after Bethpage Black at No. 7, the next public course is Atunyote at No. 38, with 30 private clubs in between.
GOLF's 2024-25 New York ranking agrees on the first three, in the same order. It has the Black at No. 8 and the Red at No. 31, the only two courses among its 40 a visitor can book, and it rates Garden City (No. 6) and Glens Falls (No. 15) higher than Golf Digest does.
How to play the ranked public courses
Best Public Golf Courses in New York sorts the state's playable courses by region, and Bethpage Black: How to Get a Tee Time covers the Black's reservation rules.
- State Parks: Bethpage and Montauk Downs, with separate rates for state residents. Montauk Downs requires registering with the State Parks reservation system before booking.
- City and town courses: Ferry Point and Dyker Beach belong to New York City. Harbor Links and Patriot Hills have rates for town residents, and Smithtown Landing has the weekend rule above.
- Resorts: Turning Stone, Leatherstocking, The Sagamore and the Monster take non-guests; book through the resort or its golf shop.
- The rest: GolfNow or the course's own tee sheet, linked from each course listing.
The season runs roughly April to November, a little longer on Long Island, and many upstate courses close for winter. The private clubs are for members and their guests only. We don't sell tee times.
