Skip to content
Golf in NYGolf in NY
Drone view of a bunkered green on the shoreline above open water at Fishers Island Club, Fishers Island, NY

Invitation & Access · Long Island: Suffolk & the Hamptons

Fishers Island ClubFishers Island

Seth Raynor's template holes on the eastern end of Fishers Island, a ferry ride from Connecticut.

Par

70

Yardage

6,597

Rating · Slope

72.8 · 144

Holes

18

Green Fee

Members only

The Course

About Fishers Island Club

Fishers Island Club is a private golf, tennis and beach club for members and their guests on the island's eastern end. The island belongs to Suffolk County, New York, but lies in Long Island Sound off New London, Connecticut, and is reached by ferry. The par-70 Seth Raynor course loops along both coastlines with views of the Sound, and it often plays firm because it has no modern fairway irrigation.

History

Fishers Island Club — History

In 1925 the second generation of the Ferguson family set out to develop the eastern two-thirds of the island as a private summer community, with Frederick Law Olmsted Jr. and Seth Raynor planning it. Raynor died in January 1926, six months before the course opened, and his protege Charles Banks completed construction. Gil Hanse has been the club's consulting architect for more than 25 years.

Design

Fishers Island Club — Design

Raynor built versions of C.B. Macdonald's ideal holes here, among them a Redan, Biarritz, Road, Double Plateau, Knoll, Eden, Cape and Short. The Fried Egg credits a routing that works from low ground out to the bold landforms of the eastern point and back, and greens set high on plateaus with fine internal ridges and pockets. Exposed to the wind and kept firm, it can play far longer than the card suggests.

What Sets It Apart

Why Play Fishers Island Club

No. 3 in Golf Digest's 2025-26 New York ranking, Fishers Island is the course Planet Golf calls Raynor's best, and The Fried Egg credits the club's resistance to change for keeping it so well preserved.

The Round

The Journey at Fishers Island Club

I.

The Opening

The 398-yard 1st is a gentle start, though its green falls away on three sides, a pattern that repeats all day. The 183-yard 2nd is a Redan. Then the land rises: the 325-yard 3rd climbs to a raised skyline green, the 417-yard 4th, the No. 1 handicap, crests an Alps hill to a hidden punchbowl green above the rocky shore, and the 225-yard 5th is a Biarritz played across a chasm. The 551-yard 6th crosses the wildest ground on the course.

II.

The Middle

The 374-yard 7th has the best view on the course, across the Sound to Connecticut. The 463-yard 8th, the longest par 4, finishes at a Road-style green angled across play, and the 361-yard 9th crests a hill to a double-plateau green pushed toward the beach. The 396-yard 10th's Knoll green repels shots on all sides, the 163-yard 11th is an Eden with deep greenside bunkers, and the 383-yard 12th is a reverse-Redan two-shotter.

III.

The Finish

The 397-yard 13th tees off toward the water, and the 418-yard 14th, the No. 2 handicap, is a Cape where hugging the left shortens the approach. The 538-yard 15th has a blind drive, the 145-yard 16th is a downhill Short, and the 417-yard 17th crosses flat ground to a green split by parallel rails. The 443-yard 18th heads across part of the harbor and climbs to a tiered green with deep bunkers and a sharp false front.

How to Play It

Fishers Island Club — Playing Strategy

Beginner / High Handicap

Expect firm ground: with no modern fairway irrigation the ball runs, so plan approaches to land short and release. Many greens are perched with fall-offs on several sides, so the center of the green is the target, especially at the 4th and 11th. A 72.8 rating and 144 slope from the Black tees make this a stern day, so take a forward tee and the safe side of deep bunkers.

Intermediate / Mid Handicap

Angles matter more than distance on a 6,597-yard par 70. On the 14th Cape, hugging the left shortens the approach, and on the 18th a longer carry down the right sets up the angle into the green. On the 5th Biarritz and the 11th Eden, know where the hole is cut before choosing a club; the wrong section of green or a deep bunker costs a stroke.

Advanced / Low Handicap

Wind off the Sound and plateau greens make approach precision the whole test. The Fried Egg points to small ridges and pockets inside the greens, so fairway position decides birdie chances, especially into the greens it singles out at the 4th, 5th, 9th, 10th, 12th, 17th and 18th. The par 5s at the 6th and 15th are the scoring holes, but the 6th's hog's-back fairway demands a centered drive.

Signature Holes

Fishers Island Club — Signature Holes

The Card

Fishers Island Club Scorecard

Hole123456789Out101112131415161718InTotal
Par434435444354344453443570
Yards3981833254172255513744633613,2973961633833974185381454174433,3006,597
Handicap7139151131715—41268214181016——

Good to Know

Fishers Island Club — questions answered

How do I get on Fishers Island Club?
Fishers Island Club is a private club — play is reserved for members and their guests. The only way on is a membership or a member's invitation; there is no public tee sheet.
Who designed Fishers Island Club?
Fishers Island Club was designed by Seth Raynor and opened in 1926.
What is the par and yardage at Fishers Island Club?
Fishers Island Club plays to a par of 70 over 6,597 yards from the championship tees, with a course rating of 72.8 and a slope of 144.
Is Fishers Island Club public or private?
Fishers Island Club is a private member club — not open to public play. Access is by membership or a member's invitation; there is no public tee sheet.
Where is Fishers Island Club located?
Fishers Island Club is located at 20449 E Main Rd, Fishers Island, NY 06390, in the Long Island: Suffolk & the Hamptons area of New York.

How to Play It

How to Play Fishers Island Club.

Fishers Island Club is a private club — play is reserved for members and their guests, with no public tee sheet. The only way on is a membership or a member's invitation.

Golf in NY is an independent guide — we don’t sell tee times or mark them up. We map the exact way on.