Skip to content
Golf in NYGolf in NY
Aerial view of a bunkered green and fescue slopes with the clubhouse beyond at St. George's Golf & Country Club, East Setauket, NY

Invitation & Access · Long Island: Suffolk & the Hamptons

St. George's Golf & Country ClubEast Setauket

Devereux Emmet's own 1917 course in Setauket, restored by Gil Hanse and little changed since opening.

Par

70

Yardage

6,335

Rating · Slope

70.8 · 134

Holes

18

Green Fee

Members only

The Course

About St. George's Golf & Country Club

St. George's is a private club for members and their guests on Long Island's North Shore, about two miles inland from the Sound. On paper the course is short, 6,335 yards at par 70 from the Championship tees, but its 70.8 rating and 134 slope reflect glacial terrain, blind shots, deep bunkers and tilted greens. Firm fairways and widened corridors let the ball run, and the wind matters more than the yardage suggests.

History

St. George's Golf & Country Club — History

Devereux Emmet gathered the founders in 1915, chose the 140-acre site and designed and built the course without a fee; it formally opened on June 23, 1917, with a Red Cross exhibition match. The club says the basic design is unchanged apart from some lengthened tees and a redesigned 11th. Gil Hanse's master plan later removed trees, expanded fairways and greens and took out asphalt cart paths.

Design

St. George's Golf & Country Club — Design

Emmet traveled the British Isles with Charles Blair Macdonald measuring famous links holes, and St. George's shows that schooling: blind shots, stacked and gathering bunkers, fields of small mounds and greens with bold tilts. Golf Club Atlas praises its startlingly unique holes and the hard-edged hazards Emmet built where nature offered little. Hanse's restoration widened corridors so balls run and fairways spill into one another across the moraine landforms.

What Sets It Apart

Why Play St. George's Golf & Country Club

Emmet built it as his own home course, and Golf Club Atlas calls it his masterpiece. It is No. 20 in Golf Digest's 2025-26 New York ranking.

The Round

The Journey at St. George's Golf & Country Club

I.

The Opening

After the 375-yard 1st, the 579-yard 2nd is the longest hole and the No. 1 handicap. Perfection, the 422-yard 3rd, plunges downhill out of sight, its leftward cant feeding drives toward the only level patch of fairway. The 374-yard 4th is the oddity: a flat front bunker hides a moat bunker deeper than most golfers are tall, below a pushed-up green walled by sand. The 365-yard 5th climbs, and the 485-yard 6th is the shorter of the front nine's two par 5s.

II.

The Middle

At the 187-yard 7th, the ground short of the green decides the shot. On the 375-yard 8th, a nine-foot-deep bunker is cut into the brow of the hill, and a blind island bunker waits farther on. The 376-yard 10th falls to a green at the base of a hill beside Lower Sheep Pasture Road. The 200-yard 11th, the one hole the club says was redesigned, plays from high point to high point, and the 425-yard 12th drops to the property's low point before rising to a benched green.

III.

The Finish

The Knoll, the 465-yard 13th, falls 26 feet from the top of the fairway to the green and served as the home hole until 1929; it is the No. 2 handicap. The 395-yard 14th climbs over a crowned fairway, the 171-yard 15th has a humped, domed green, and the 326-yard 16th is a drive and pitch to a small green. The 130-yard 17th sits behind two 13-foot-deep bunkers, and the 537-yard par-5 18th crosses broken, bunkered ground to a two-tiered green.

How to Play It

St. George's Golf & Country Club — Playing Strategy

Beginner / High Handicap

Do not judge St. George's by its 6,335 yards. Play for the middle of the 4th and 17th greens, where the bunkers are deep enough to cost several shots, and accept that some tee shots will finish out of sight. On the 18th, stay away from the bunkered ground in the middle and pitch on in three, as most golfers do.

Intermediate / Mid Handicap

Use the ground. The 10th green accepts low, running approaches, while the 11th rewards a high shot that holds a tilted surface; coming up short or right leaves a daunting pitch. On the 13th, too long a drive leaves a blind approach and too short cannot reach, so club for the landing spot. On the 15th, the safe miss to the left can leave a putt across the humps.

Advanced / Low Handicap

The short card invites low scores, but Golf Club Atlas notes birdies rarely come in bunches here, and the 16th and 17th greens together barely exceed 6,100 square feet. On the 3rd, a drive down the left finds the only level lie. The 18th can be reached in two with a strong fairway wood, but the upper tier is the harder half of the green.

Signature Holes

St. George's Golf & Country Club — Signature Holes

The Card

St. George's Golf & Country Club Scorecard

Hole123456789Out101112131415161718InTotal
Par454445343364344434353470
Yards3755794223743654851873751483,3103762004254653951713261305373,0256,335
Handicap9173111315517—10124281614186——

Good to Know

St. George's Golf & Country Club — questions answered

How do I get on St. George's Golf & Country Club?
St. George's Golf & Country Club is a private club — play is reserved for members and their guests. The only way on is a membership or a member's invitation; there is no public tee sheet.
Who designed St. George's Golf & Country Club?
St. George's Golf & Country Club was designed by Devereux Emmet and opened in 1917.
What is the par and yardage at St. George's Golf & Country Club?
St. George's Golf & Country Club plays to a par of 70 over 6,335 yards from the championship tees, with a course rating of 70.8 and a slope of 134.
Is St. George's Golf & Country Club public or private?
St. George's Golf & Country Club is a private member club — not open to public play. Access is by membership or a member's invitation; there is no public tee sheet.
Where is St. George's Golf & Country Club located?
St. George's Golf & Country Club is located at 134 Lower Sheep Pasture Road, Setauket, NY 11733, in the Long Island: Suffolk & the Hamptons area of New York.

How to Play It

How to Play St. George's Golf & Country Club.

St. George's Golf & Country Club is a private club — play is reserved for members and their guests, with no public tee sheet. The only way on is a membership or a member's invitation.

Golf in NY is an independent guide — we don’t sell tee times or mark them up. We map the exact way on.