Skip to content
Golf in NYGolf in NY
Best Golf Courses in Buffalo & Western New York

Where to Play

Best Golf Courses in Buffalo & Western New York

Public tee times from Niagara to Chautauqua, and the Buffalo clubs that stay private

Updated · November 20, 2026

Buffalo's golf reputation rests on private clubs designed by Donald Ross, Colt & Alison and A.W. Tillinghast. The public side deserves more credit: Robert Trent Jones courses by father and son, the site of the 1912 U.S. Open, a Ross 18 above Chautauqua Lake and golf on two ski hills. This guide is for the golfer who wants a tee time. Buffalo is five to six hours from New York City; the full list is on the Western New York page.

Buffalo, Niagara and the northern suburbs

Seneca Hickory Stick, Lewiston

Seneca Hickory Stick Golf Course is the course to build a trip around, and the region's only course named on Golf Digest's Best Public Courses in New York list (September 2025). The Seneca Gaming Corporation built it for the Seneca Nation off Interstate 190, near the Lewiston-Queenston border crossing. Bruce Charlton led the design with Robert Trent Jones Jr., and it opened in July 2010; GOLF Magazine then put it sixth among that year's best new public courses. The par 72 runs 6,967 yards, rated 74.4 with a 142 slope. Its signature is shared ground: the 10th and 18th use one double fairway, and the 9th and 18th share a green. Carts are included and walking is allowed.

Glen Oak, East Amherst

Glen Oak Golf Course has the longest card in this guide and the highest rating of its public courses: 7,310 yards from the back tees, 75.4 with a 142 slope. Robert Trent Jones Sr. designed it in 1969, and it was private until 1985. Water is in play on ten holes, and the Jones signatures are all there: runway tees, double-dogleg par 5s and big greens, some on two or three tiers.

Grover Cleveland, Buffalo

Grover Cleveland Golf Course, an Erie County course at the Buffalo-Amherst line, is where the history is. It was the second home of The Country Club of Buffalo, and John McDermott won the 1912 U.S. Open on it; nine holes from that week are still in play. Walter Travis reworked Ganson Depew's 1902 layout for the Open and Donald Ross redesigned it in 1917-18, so the county calls it the only public course in North America designed by both. It is a par 69 of 5,564 yards from the White tees, but Ross's greens at the 3rd, 14th, 17th and 18th hold their own, and the 17th is a Redan-style par 3.

South and east of the city

Harvest Hill, Orchard Park

Harvest Hill Golf Course began with 125 acres that Carl and Marion Lambein gave the West Seneca Rotary Foundation in 1997 for a public course. Michael Hurdzan, the lead designer of Erin Hills, routed it through wetland, woods and golden heather, and it opened in 2007. It is 7,021 yards from the Black tees, rated 74.1 with a 130 slope, with five par 5s and five par 3s; BuffaloGolfer called those par 5s the best set in Western New York, public or private. The First Tee Western New York is based here.

Arrowhead, Akron

Arrowhead Golf Club is the pick for golfers who like wind. Scott Witter laid it over 164 acres of former farmland west of Akron, and it opened in 2003 with fescue, six ponds and more than 60 bunkers, but few trees to slow the prevailing west wind. Interrupted fairways and mounds that hide part of the target make it play harder than 6,520 yards from the Blue tees suggests; the slope is 137. The USGA used it as a qualifying site for the 2005 U.S. Senior Open.

Batavia Country Club, Batavia

Batavia Country Club, near an Interstate 90 exit between Buffalo and Rochester, is long and light on sand: 7,180 yards from the Blue tees, rated 74.7, and On The Tee magazine counted nine bunkers when it reviewed the course. Big, sloping greens do the defending. It is public but also sells memberships, and groups teeing off after 3 p.m. must include a member. The Rochester end of that drive is in the Rochester & Finger Lakes guide.

Byrncliff Golf Resort, Varysburg

Byrncliff Golf Resort answers the weekend question: a family-run property with hotel rooms, a restaurant and stay-and-play packages beside a public par 72 in the Wyoming County hills, about 35 minutes from Buffalo. At 6,687 yards with a 117 slope it is one of the friendlier cards here, though the routing climbs and drops across ridges. The club says its par 5s are all reachable on a good day and that the course stays open year-round, weather permitting.

Chautauqua and the ski hills

Chautauqua Golf Club: the Lake and the Hill

The Chautauqua Institution owns this club, and its two public 18s are worth keeping apart. The Lake Course is a Donald Ross design the club dates to 1924, on a broad hillside falling toward Chautauqua Lake. It is generous off the tee; the trouble is the approach, to small, steeply pitched greens that mostly tilt toward the water. Building the Hill Course cost the Lake three of Ross's holes, and the club's 2020 master plan would bring them back. It plays 6,470 yards with a 135 slope.

The Hill Course, by Xen Hassenplug, sits higher and plays harder despite being shorter: 6,413 yards, with a 144 slope from the Blue tees, through tree-lined doglegs to small greens that nearly all lean toward the lake. Its date is unsettled: 1994 on the club's course page, the mid-1980s in a 2020 Institution release. Both courses take the public at daily rates.

Holiday Valley, Ellicottville

Holiday Valley's Double Black Diamond course plays like two courses. The 1958 front nine is fairly flat, with ponds and sod-wall bunkers; the 1989 back nine works through the base of the ski hills, with ravines, side-hill lies and narrow fairways. Director of golf Steve Carney says the front leaves golfers thinking the course is easy. Seven holes sit under downhill ski runs, and the 7th tee is set into the hill below The Wall, the resort's double-black-diamond slope. The par 70 runs 6,493 yards with a 130 slope and is open to the public at posted daily rates.

Peek'n Peak, Clymer

Peek'n Peak's Upper Course has the professional tour history. John Exley routed it atop the ski hill, and it hosted Nationwide Tour events from 2002 to 2007 and, starting in 2016, the LECOM Health Challenge. The resort lists it at par 72 with five sets of tees from about 4,800 to 7,000 yards, warns that its greens are lightning-quick, and takes public golfers as well as resort guests. Clymer is a short drive from Erie, Pennsylvania.

The private clubs

On the Lake Erie shore in Dunkirk, Shorewood Country Club is a private club. By its own rules, guests must be accompanied by a member and are limited to three rounds a season; it also offers a summer membership of up to two months to families living more than 100 miles away.

The courses that made Buffalo's name are for members and their guests. The Country Club of Buffalo's 1926 Donald Ross course in Williamsville, routed around an old limestone quarry, is No. 28 in Golf Digest's 2025-26 ranking of New York's best courses. Crag Burn Golf Club, Robert Trent Jones Sr.'s 1972 course in East Aurora, is No. 36 on that list, and Park Country Club, the Colt & Alison course in Williamsville where Paul Runyan won the 1934 PGA Championship, is No. 54.

A.W. Tillinghast's Niagara Falls Country Club in Lewiston has hosted the Porter Cup amateur since 1959, and Phil Mickelson won it twice. Ben Hogan won the 1948 Western Open at Brookfield Country Club in Clarence. Wanakah Country Club, founded in 1899, sits above Lake Erie in Hamburg; Orchard Park Country Club has a 1917 Walter J. Travis course; and Cloverbank Country Club began in 1959 as Bethlehem Steel's management club.

How to book

Public courses take tee times through GolfNow or their own tee sheets, and each course listing links the right one. At Grover Cleveland, annual pass holders book seven days ahead and the general public three. Arrowhead opens its sheet 14 days out and wants Friday-to-Sunday rounds prepaid, and Batavia's non-members book weekend times online. Holiday Valley, Peek'n Peak and Byrncliff book through the resort, with stay-and-play or resort packages. Shorewood's guests play with a member, and the private clubs have no public booking route.

New York golf runs roughly April to November, and many upstate courses close for winter. For more, see the best golf resorts in New York, when to golf in New York and the best public golf courses in New York.