Skip to content
Golf in NYGolf in NY
Aerial view down a fairway past a shrub island and a sand bunker in golden evening light at Mill Creek Golf Club, Churchville, NY

Public Play · Finger Lakes & Rochester

Mill Creek Golf ClubChurchville

Hearn and Albanese's hilltop public course in Churchville, west of Rochester.

Par

71

Yardage

6,876

Rating · Slope

73.7 · 138

Holes

18

Green Fee

$17–$50

The Course

About Mill Creek Golf Club

Mill Creek is a public course in Churchville on the highest point in Monroe County, with views of the Rochester skyline to the east and Finger Lakes hills to the south. A glacial drumlin cuts through its 320 acres of forested, rolling hills and fescue. From the Black tees it plays 6,876 yards at par 71, with a 73.7 rating and 138 slope, and five tee sets start under 5,000 yards.

History

Mill Creek Golf Club — History

Built on the former Sackett family farm, Mill Creek began construction in 2003 and opened to the public in 2005; an earlier executive course is now closed. The 10th, designed as a par 4, was later turned into a downhill par 3, making the course a par 71. Chris and Leslie Gallea bought it in 2016 and began with the greens, then the bunkers. It hosted RDGA Match Play Championships in 2009 and 2019.

Design

Mill Creek Golf Club — Design

Ray Hearn and Paul Albanese blended the land's natural look with risk-reward choices. The RDGA describes a classic American-style links feel, with wild areas between holes, several blind tee shots, a mix of narrow and wide fairways and multi-tiered greens. The bentgrass greens are large, averaging over 6,000 square feet, with mild undulations.

What Sets It Apart

Why Play Mill Creek Golf Club

Mill Creek sits on the highest point in Monroe County, and when it hosted the 2019 RDGA Match Play the association called it one of the most recent entries on the Rochester-area golf scene.

The Round

The Journey at Mill Creek Golf Club

I.

The Opening

Mill Creek opens with a 440-yard par 4, then the 551-yard 2nd, the first of four par 5s. The 431-yard 3rd and 420-yard 4th are long two-shotters, and the 503-yard 5th is the shortest par 5. The 229-yard 6th, the first of five par 3s, is the No. 4 handicap.

II.

The Middle

The 435-yard 7th is the No. 2 handicap, and the 326-yard 8th is the shortest par 4. The 166-yard 9th offers one of the course's signature views, up the hill behind the green. The 235-yard 10th, now a downhill par 3, was designed as a dogleg-left par 4. The 526-yard 11th climbs back toward the clubhouse hill on a fairway split twice, and the 210-yard 12th follows.

III.

The Finish

The 394-yard 13th leads to the 470-yard 14th, the longest par 4 and the No. 1 handicap. The 582-yard 15th is the longest hole on the course. The 417-yard 16th and the 197-yard 17th, the fifth par 3, set up a 344-yard closing par 4. The back nine is par 35 at 3,375 yards.

How to Play It

Mill Creek Golf Club — Playing Strategy

Beginner / High Handicap

Five tee sets let players choose a course from under 5,000 yards, and a forward set makes sense against a 138 slope. The RDGA notes wide, forgiving fairways, but some tee shots are blind, so check the line first. The large greens have mild undulations, so focus on reaching them rather than attacking the flag.

Intermediate / Mid Handicap

Pick your fairway on the 11th, where the split offers a higher or lower route off the tee and again on the second shot. Five par 3s, three of them over 200 yards, decide many cards, so take enough club on the 6th, 10th and 12th. The 14th, the No. 1 handicap, is a 470-yard par 4 where bogey is acceptable.

Advanced / Low Handicap

In 2019 the club's head pro told the RDGA that local knowledge of the course's subtleties is an edge, especially in match play. The par 5s are the openings, led by the 503-yard 5th, while the 582-yard 15th rarely is one. The long par 3s and the 470-yard 14th protect a 73.7 rating, and the multi-tiered greens punish approaches to the wrong level.

Signature Holes

Mill Creek Golf Club — Signature Holes

The Card

Mill Creek Golf Club Scorecard

Hole123456789Out101112131415161718InTotal
Par454453443363534454343571
Yards4405514314205032294353261663,5012355262103944705824171973443,3756,876
Handicap10148126421618—1731571511139——

Good to Know

Mill Creek Golf Club — questions answered

How do I book a tee time at Mill Creek Golf Club?
Find and book live tee times at Mill Creek Golf Club through GolfNow — Golf in NY links straight to its tee sheet on this listing.
How much does it cost to play Mill Creek Golf Club?
Green fees at Mill Creek Golf Club are typically $17 to $50, varying by season, day of week and time. Confirm current rates when you book.
Who designed Mill Creek Golf Club?
Mill Creek Golf Club was designed by Ray Hearn and Paul Albanese and opened in 2005.
What is the par and yardage at Mill Creek Golf Club?
Mill Creek Golf Club plays to a par of 71 over 6,876 yards from the championship tees, with a course rating of 73.7 and a slope of 138.
Is Mill Creek Golf Club public or private?
Mill Creek Golf Club is open to public play. Tee times can be reserved in advance.
Where is Mill Creek Golf Club located?
Mill Creek Golf Club is located at 128 Cedars Ave, Churchville, NY 14428, in the Finger Lakes & Rochester area of New York.

How to Play It

Book a Tee Time at Mill Creek Golf Club.

Find and book live tee times at Mill Creek Golf Club on GolfNow.

Golf in NY is an independent guide — we don’t sell tee times or mark them up. We map the exact way on.