Skip to content
Golf in NYGolf in NY
Blue-flagged green beneath a large autumn hardwood and rolling mounds at Midvale Country Club, Penfield, NY

Invitation & Access · Finger Lakes & Rochester

Midvale Country ClubPenfield

Robert Trent Jones Sr.'s first 18-hole design, at a private club in Penfield.

Par

72

Yardage

6,544

Rating · Slope

72.6 · 139

Holes

18

Green Fee

Members only

The Course

About Midvale Country Club

Midvale is a private club for members and their guests on Baird Road in Penfield, at the highest point in the town. Its 144 acres of rolling hills hold the first 18-hole course Robert Trent Jones Sr. designed. From the Black tees it plays 6,544 yards at par 72, with a 72.6 rating and 139 slope. The club runs without tee times and says rounds take under four hours.

History

Midvale Country Club — History

East Rochester businessmen formed Midvale in 1929 after losing the land under their Hillcrest Club. Robert Barrett, who had built greens at Oak Hill and Monroe for Donald Ross's construction engineer, helped choose and build the site. Stanley Thompson's firm was hired for the routing, and Jones, then working with Thompson, served as primary architect. The course opened in 1931.

Design

Midvale Country Club — Design

The founders wanted rolling topography, good natural drainage and no factory smoke, and they chose a Baird Road farm and fruit orchard. Jones routed his first 18 across that ground. The card is balanced at 36-36, with two par 5s on each nine and a closing par 3, and the club describes a layout that is challenging yet playable.

What Sets It Apart

Why Play Midvale Country Club

Midvale holds Robert Trent Jones Sr.'s first 18-hole design, built in his Thompson and Jones days, and members play it without tee times on a course the club keeps to rounds under four hours.

The Round

The Journey at Midvale Country Club

I.

The Opening

Midvale opens with two par 4s of 412 and 383 yards, then the 538-yard 3rd, the longest hole on the course and the No. 5 handicap. The 180-yard 4th is the first par 3. The 369-yard 5th leads to the 420-yard 6th, the longest par 4 on the card and the No. 1 handicap.

II.

The Middle

The 322-yard 7th is the shortest par 4. The 527-yard 8th, the No. 3 handicap, and the 145-yard 9th, the shortest hole, close a 3,296-yard front. The back nine starts on a par 5, the 489-yard 10th, then continues with the 391-yard 11th and the 336-yard 12th.

III.

The Finish

The 235-yard 13th is the longest par 3 yet carries the No. 18 handicap, and the 405-yard 14th is the No. 2. The 380-yard 15th and 353-yard 16th lead to the 469-yard 17th, the shortest par 5 and the No. 4 handicap. Midvale finishes on a par 3, the 190-yard 18th, closing a 3,248-yard back nine.

How to Play It

Midvale Country Club — Playing Strategy

Beginner / High Handicap

A 139 slope from the Black tees argues for a forward set. The 145-yard 9th and the short par 4s, the 322-yard 7th and 336-yard 12th, are the best chances. The 235-yard 13th is long but carries the No. 18 handicap, so a bogey there costs little.

Intermediate / Mid Handicap

The 6th and 14th, the top two handicap holes, are par 4s of 420 and 405 yards, so the plan is a fairway and a center-green approach. Score on the 469-yard 17th and 489-yard 10th, the shortest par 5s, and take enough club on the closing 190-yard par 3.

Advanced / Low Handicap

With a 72.6 rating at par 72, the par 5s carry most of the birdie chances, and the 469-yard 17th and 489-yard 10th are in two-shot range for long hitters. The 538-yard 3rd and 527-yard 8th are the front's longest tests, and the 235-yard 13th demands a long iron or wood. Finish with a crisp iron on the 190-yard 18th.

Signature Holes

Midvale Country Club — Signature Holes

The Card

Midvale Country Club Scorecard

Hole123456789Out101112131415161718InTotal
Par445344453365443444533672
Yards4123835381803694203225271453,2964893913362354053803534691903,2486,544
Handicap7115179113315—61012182814416——

Good to Know

Midvale Country Club — questions answered

How do I get on Midvale Country Club?
Midvale Country Club is a private club — play is reserved for members and their guests. The only way on is a membership or a member's invitation; there is no public tee sheet.
Who designed Midvale Country Club?
Midvale Country Club was designed by Robert Trent Jones Sr. and opened in 1931.
What is the par and yardage at Midvale Country Club?
Midvale Country Club plays to a par of 72 over 6,544 yards from the championship tees, with a course rating of 72.6 and a slope of 139.
Is Midvale Country Club public or private?
Midvale Country Club is a private member club — not open to public play. Access is by membership or a member's invitation; there is no public tee sheet.
Where is Midvale Country Club located?
Midvale Country Club is located at 2387 Baird Road, Penfield, NY 14526, in the Finger Lakes & Rochester area of New York.

How to Play It

How to Play Midvale Country Club.

Midvale Country Club is a private club — play is reserved for members and their guests, with no public tee sheet. The only way on is a membership or a member's invitation.

Golf in NY is an independent guide — we don’t sell tee times or mark them up. We map the exact way on.