Skip to content
Golf in NYGolf in NY
Sunlit fairway framed by tall pines and shade trees with wooded hills beyond at Elmira Country Club, Elmira, NY

Invitation & Access · Southern Tier

Elmira Country ClubElmira

A member-owned Elmira club since 1897, built on Willie Dunn and A.W. Tillinghast nines

Par

72

Yardage

6,707

Rating · Slope

73.7 · 135

Holes

18

Green Fee

Members only

The Course

About Elmira Country Club

Elmira Country Club is a member-owned private club for members and their guests, founded in 1897 and set on West Church Street. Its 18 holes play to par 72 and 6,707 yards from the black tees, with a 73.7 rating and a 135 slope. It is a full country club rather than a golf-only retreat: a pool, tennis, a fitness center, card rooms and a ballroom seating 400 sit alongside the course and practice greens.

History

Elmira Country Club — History

Founder J. Sloat Fassett brought the game home from Scotland, and the club was incorporated on October 21, 1897, with 317 charter members. Willie Dunn's first nine opened the following year, beside a farmhouse clubhouse that stood near today's 11th tee. A.W. Tillinghast designed the nine to the east in 1922. Ferdinand Garvin added five holes in 1970, replacing part of the old layout, and Stephen Kay led improvements from 1991.

Design

Elmira Country Club — Design

Elmira is a composite course rather than one architect's plan. Willie Dunn's 1898 holes, Tillinghast's 1922 eastern nine and Ferdinand Garvin's five 1970 holes share the routing, and Stephen Kay's work from 1991 was meant, in the club's words, to keep it a championship-quality test. The card is lopsided: a par-35 front of 3,245 yards and a par-37 back of 3,462 that holds two of the three par 5s.

What Sets It Apart

Why Play Elmira Country Club

A club since 1897, Elmira has hosted the New York State Amateur four times, in 1957, 1983, 1997 and 2012, as well as the state Mid-Amateur.

The Round

The Journey at Elmira Country Club

I.

The Opening

There is no soft start. The 398-yard 1st is the No. 3 handicap, and the 396-yard 2nd and 346-yard 3rd keep the run of par 4s going. The 133-yard 4th is the shortest hole on the card and rated No. 17. Then comes the 537-yard 5th, a par 5 and the No. 1 handicap, followed by the 410-yard 6th.

II.

The Middle

The 175-yard 7th is the second par 3 on the front, and the outward half closes with the 407-yard 8th and the 443-yard 9th. The back nine starts hard: the 485-yard 10th is a par 5 rated No. 4, and the 473-yard 11th, the longest par 4 on the card, is the No. 2 handicap. The 334-yard 12th gives a little back.

III.

The Finish

The closing six mix short and long. The 377-yard 13th and the 309-yard 14th, the shortest par 4 on the course, lead to the 190-yard 15th, the last of only three par 3s. The 515-yard 16th is the final par 5 and rated No. 6, and two par 4s of 413 and 366 yards finish the round.

How to Play It

Elmira Country Club — Playing Strategy

Beginner / High Handicap

At 6,707 yards and a 135 slope from the black tees, a first-time guest should play forward. Treat the 537-yard 5th as a three-shot hole and use the handicap strokes there and at the 473-yard 11th. The 133-yard 4th and the 309-yard 14th are the best chances for a par.

Intermediate / Mid Handicap

The front nine is the place to score: par 35, with the No. 1 handicap at the 5th but three par 4s under 400 yards to open. Hold something back for the inward half, which runs 217 yards longer and starts with the 10th and 11th, rated No. 4 and No. 2. Bogey on that pair is no disaster.

Advanced / Low Handicap

A 73.7 rating against par 72 means the black tees play over par even for a scratch player. The par 5s at the 10th (485 yards) and 16th (515) are the likeliest birdies; the 537-yard 5th carries the No. 1 handicap. The 443-yard 9th and 473-yard 11th are the longest par 4s, where a round is protected rather than built.

Signature Holes

Elmira Country Club — Signature Holes

The Card

Elmira Country Club Scorecard

Hole123456789Out101112131415161718InTotal
Par444354344355444435443772
Yards3983963461335374101754074433,2454854733343773091905154133663,4626,707
Handicap3971715151311—42168141861012——

Good to Know

Elmira Country Club — questions answered

How do I get on Elmira Country Club?
Elmira Country Club is a private club — play is reserved for members and their guests. The only way on is a membership or a member's invitation; there is no public tee sheet.
Who designed Elmira Country Club?
Elmira Country Club was designed by Willie Dunn and A.W. Tillinghast.
What is the par and yardage at Elmira Country Club?
Elmira Country Club plays to a par of 72 over 6,707 yards from the championship tees, with a course rating of 73.7 and a slope of 135.
Is Elmira Country Club public or private?
Elmira Country Club is a private member club — not open to public play. Access is by membership or a member's invitation; there is no public tee sheet.
Where is Elmira Country Club located?
Elmira Country Club is located at 1538 West Church Street, Elmira, NY 14905, in the Southern Tier area of New York.

How to Play It

How to Play Elmira Country Club.

Elmira Country Club is a private club — play is reserved for members and their guests, with no public tee sheet. The only way on is a membership or a member's invitation.

Golf in NY is an independent guide — we don’t sell tee times or mark them up. We map the exact way on.